Okay--so Jeff Beck has to be the best guitarist around today if his playing on the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame 25th Anniversary celebration was anything to go by--wow! Two nights of musical collaboration and celebration rolled into a four-hour tv special what a great way to spend a Sunday evening--like going to church or something! Bono, offered up the metaphor of the rock and roll audience, gathered in the New York temple of rock (Madison Square Garden) as the great unwashed congregation--pilgrims and pioneers, saints and heretics, poets and punks, all lifting up the power of music. Rock is essentially about liberation he proclaimed, "political, sexual, spiritual," different kinds of liberation for different people and there were all kinds of liberation offered up.
Mick Jagger injected some feral sexual liberation into U2's Stuck In A Moment, and Bono looked almost rattled when Fergie and Jagger traded leers and licks on Gimme Shelter, but ably backed by Edge and the boys it was a fierce rendition of a classic song. Classics from Smokey Robinson to Ozzy were infused with new life by the fan/bands that backed them. Perhaps the highlight for me was Sam Moore (Sam+Dave) backed by Bruce and the E Street band--Hold On I'm Coming and Soul Man never sounded better. Stevie Wonder, Jackson Browne, Patti Smith, BB King--there were some great moments, but more than the sum total of its parts there was the deep sense of magic and wonder that inhabits popular music, or at least has up till now.
I don't know if music matters the way it used to, I don't know if it even can be (or ever really was) generation defining the way it was in a much less connected and digitized world. I think it still matters and still means stuff, just not in the same way. I am not a nostalgist, I don't think all the best music has already been done, in fact, I think the past couple of years have been amazingly creative musically--but it is a different world and different worlds make meaning in different ways--music plays a role just not the same one, but for one night in New York (two really) a congregation was assembled, a liturgy prepared and a people in darkness caught glimpses of light.